Best Car Rental Companies in New York

New York City is one of the most popular travel destinations in the world. Millions of people visit the city every year, and many of them need to rent a car. There are a lot of car rental companies in New York City, and it can be hard to know which one to choose.

In this article, we will talk about the best car rentals in New York City, whether you need a large van for a family vacation or a small car to move around the city, all these companies are present in many locations around downtown, Manhattan, JFK Airport, LaGuardia Airport or Newark Airport.

This is the ultimate ranking of the TOP CAR RENTAL companies in NEW YORK CITY in 2024.

#1. National (8.8/10) 🏆

National Car Rental is the Best Car Rental in NYC 🏆. National, along with Alamo, is a subsidiary of Enterprise, and for a full lineup of great New York City car rentals, National is one of the best places to rent. In fact, any of the subsidiaries of the Enterprise Holdings group is a good choice for renting, as all three are among the top 4 companies in NYC.

They have the cars you need for your family vacation or business trip. If you’re going on vacation, you might have to take a lot of stuff. With a large van from National Car Rental, you can fit everything in with no problem. They also offer cheap SUVs and luxury sedans so that every person in your group can travel comfortably. If you’re going to be driving in New York City, then you will need a car with a useful navigation system.

When you rent from National Car Rental, they will make sure that you have a safe and smooth drive. The customer service here is some of the best in the industry. You do not have to worry about anything when it comes to your car rental because they will take care of everything for you.

• National Car Rental is located at JFK Airport, LaGuardia Airport, Newark Airport, Manhattan, Brooklyn, and up to 10 locations more in NYC.

National customer rating:

• ⭐ Excellent overall value for money
• ⭐ Excellent cleanliness of the car
• ✔️ Very Good Service at the rental desk
• ✔️ Quick Car hire pick-up process
• ✔️ Quick Car hire drop-off process

Book Now!

#2. Alamo (8.6/10) 🥈

Regarded as one of the best car rental companies in New York City by many people, Alamo is one of the best and is on top of the list. They have several price options, so you will never be overcharged for the vehicle you need for your trip.

Their cars are top-of-the-line, and they are always in good condition. These vehicles are kept perfect by Alamo personnel who know their vehicles like the back of their hands. If you want to rent a car from New York City, then Alamo is a good option that won’t disappoint you. They have a variety of vehicles including sedans and SUVs to help you navigate the city.

When you rent from Alamo, they will make sure that your car is clean and ready to go. Their customer service is some of the best in the industry, and they will take care of whatever you need. They will give you free fuel delivery or pick-up if you need it. You do not have to worry when it comes to your car rental because Alamo is there for you.

• Alamo is also a subsidiary of Enterprise, so, its offices are shared with National and Enterprise. Thus, they are also located at JFK Airport, LaGuardia Airport, Newark Airport, Manhattan, Brooklyn, and up to 10 locations more in NYC.

Alamo customer rating:

• ⭐ Excellent overall value for money
• ⭐ Excellent cleanliness of the car
• ✔️ Very Good Service at the rental desk
• ✔️ Quick Car hire pick-up process
• ✔️ Quick Car hire drop-off process

Book Now!

#3. Avis (8.4/10) 🥉

Avis is one of the best car rentals in New York City, and they have been around for more than 50 years. If you want to rent a luxury car, then Avis has you covered. They offer a wide range of vehicles for both business and personal travelers. Their rentals are competitively priced, and they will help you save money if you’re on a tight budget. You do not have to worry about getting lost or being late when you rent from Avis Car Rental. They have many vehicles in their yard that will get you where you need to go.

When it comes to getting your car from New York City, then Avis is a good choice and will not disappoint you. They have a large staff that knows the city well, and they will help you navigate the area easily. Renting a car from Avis is another option that’s on top of the list.

• AVIS is located at JFK Airport, LaGuardia Airport, Newark Airport, Manhattan, Queens, Brooklyn, Staten Island, and up to 15 locations more in NYC.

Avis customer rating:

• ⭐ Excellent overall value for money
• ✔️ Very Good cleanliness of the car
• ✔️ Very Good Service at the rental desk
• ✔️ Quick Car hire pick-up process
• ✔️ Quick Car hire drop-off process

Book Now!

#4. Enterprise (8.2/10)

If you need a New York City car rental that you can trust, then Enterprise is a good choice. They offer safe and comfortable cars so that you will not be late for work or your next appointment. If the weather is clear, then you can enjoy a nice drive on the open road with Enterprise Rent-A-Car.

The staff is friendly and knowledgeable, and they will help you find what you need when it comes to renting your car in New York City. You do not have to worry about anything when you rent from Enterprise Rent-A-Car. They will help you pick out a vehicle that will meet your needs and fit your budget. If you have any questions, they are more than happy to answer all of them so that you can make the right choice. When it comes to locating a New York City car rental, then this company is one of the best and is on top of the list.

• Enterprise offices are shared with National and Enterprise. Thus, they are also located at JFK Airport, LaGuardia Airport, Newark Airport, Manhattan, Brooklyn, and up to 10 locations more in NYC.

Enterprise customer rating:

• ⭐ Excellent overall value for money
• ✔️ Very Good cleanliness of the car
• ✔️ Very Good Service at the rental desk
• ✔️ Quick Car hire pick-up process
• ✔️ Quick Car hire drop-off process

Book Now!

#5. Hertz (7.4/10)

Hertz is the sixth among the most highly rated car rental companies in New York. Their staff is friendly and helpful, which makes for an enjoyable car rental experience. They have a wide variety of cars to choose from, so you will never have to worry about the vehicle you need for your trip. If you’re looking to rent a car in New York City, then Hertz is a perfect choice that won’t disappoint you.

They have a fleet of vehicles to choose from and are highly trained so that they can help every customer find what they need no matter what it may be. The best thing about Hertz is that they never overcharge you. You will be surprised at how easy it is to rent a vehicle from Hertz. You can count on Hertz to provide you with a smooth and fast car rental experience. When you choose this company for your New York car rental, then you will have the perfect vehicle for your needs and still make it on time for your next appointment.

• Hertz is located at JFK Airport, LaGuardia Airport, Newark Airport, Manhattan, Queens, Brooklyn, Bronx, and up to 15 locations more in NYC.

Hertz customer rating:

• ✔️ Very Good overall value for money
• ✔️ Very Good cleanliness of the car
• ✔️ Very Good Service at the rental desk
• ✔️ Quick Car hire pick-up process
• ✔️ Quick Car hire drop-off process

Book Now!

#6. SIXT (7.1/10)

Sixt is one of the top car rental companies in New York, and its staff has years of experience. Sixt is a supplier specialized in offering high-end vehicles, but at very affordable prices. When you rent from Sixt, then you will have the perfect vehicle for your next trip or business trip. You do not have to worry about anything because they will take care of everything for you.

If you want to rent a car in New York City with a full tank of gas included, then Sixt is a good choice that won’t disappoint you. You can easily find what you need by simply visiting their website. SIXT will help you pick out your rental car for your trip so that you can have a safe and smooth drive. They also offer luxury cars with GPS systems to make sure that you will not get lost. This company is on top of the list of people in New York City.

• Sixt is located at JFK Airport, LaGuardia Airport, Newark Airport, and 2 additional offices in Manhattan.

Sixt customer rating:

• ✔️ Very Good overall value for money
• ✔️ Good cleanliness of the car
• ✔️ Good Service at the rental desk
• ✔️ Quick Car hire pick-up process
• ✔️ Quick Car hire drop-off process

Book Now!

#7. Payless (6.6/10)

For those who are looking for the cheapest car rental in NYC then Payless Car Rental is one of the best choices. This car rental company is affordable and reliable, which makes it an ideal choice.

They offer a wide range of vehicles and are always in good condition. You do not have to worry about anything when you rent from Payless Car Rental because they will take care of everything for you. If you want to find some nice and clean cars for your trip, then Payless Car Rental is your best choice that won’t disappoint you. This rental company will help you move around and experience the life of this modern city by giving you a safe and smooth ride.

The service you will receive here will be top-notch. You will not be disappointed when you choose this car rental company from New York City. The good thing is that they offer various cars, including sedans, SUVs, and vans. You can find what you need and pay a very low price in return.

• SIXT is located at JFK Airport, LaGuardia Airport, Newark Airport, and 1 additional office in Manhattan.

Payless customer rating:

• ✔️ Good overall value for money
• ✔️ Good cleanliness of the car
• ✔️ Good Service at the rental desk
• ✔️ Quick Car hire pick-up process
• ✔️ Quick Car hire drop-off process

Book Now!

#8. Budget (6.2/10)

If you are looking for a New York City car rental with the best customer service, then Budget is for you.

They have a variety of rental cars, and you can choose from so you shouldn’t be worried about anything. New York City car rental is not just for tourists; it’s a good option for business people too.

Their rates are competitive, and you can rent a car to get from one place to the next. The staff here is friendly and knowledgeable, and they know what you need. They know the city well and will help you get to where you want to go. If you’re moving to or from New York City, then this is a great option for your car or van rental.

They will ensure you have a smooth stay by offering you a quality car to help you move around and explore the city. You do not have to worry about anything when it comes to Budget Car Rental in New York. Wherever you go, they will be there to help you.

• BUDGET is a subsidiary of AVIS, so, its offices are shared with AVIS. BUDGET is located at JFK Airport, LaGuardia Airport, Newark Airport, Manhattan, Queens, Brooklyn, Staten Island, and up to 15 locations more in NYC.

Budget customer rating:

• ✔️ Good overall value for money
• ✔️ Good cleanliness of the car
• ✔️ Good Service at the rental desk
• ✔️ Quick Car hire pick-up process
• ✔️ Quick Car hire drop-off process

Book Now!

#9. Thrifty (6.0/10)

Thrifty has a large fleet of vehicles available to choose from. They offer luxury and economy-style cars that will match your needs and fit your budget. If you want to rent a car in New York City, then Thrifty is one of the best choices.

The staff here is professional, friendly, and helpful. They will take care of everything for you so that you can have a safe and smooth ride during your trip or business trip. You can easily find what you need by visiting their website. They will enable you to explore the city of New York in style because they will offer you a nice vehicle as part of their fleet.

You do not have to worry about getting a late start because they open early and close late so that everyone can get the car that they need for their trip or business trip. If you want to find some nice cars at affordable prices, then Thrifty is the place for you.

• Thrifty is a subsidiary of Hertz and is located at JFK Airport, LaGuardia Airport, Newark Airport, Manhattan, and Brooklyn.

Thrifty customer rating:

• 🟡 Regular overall value for money
• ✔️ Good cleanliness of the car
• 🟡 Poor Service at the rental desk
• 🟡 Slow Car hire pick-up process
• ✔️ Quick Car hire drop-off process

Book Now!

#10. Dollar (5.8/10)

If you need a New York car rental that will provide you with a safe and secure ride, then Dollar Car Rental is more than happy to help you out.

The staff here is professional, friendly, and knowledgeable. They have the best cars at reasonable prices. You can easily find what you need by simply visiting their website to book a car rental quickly and easily. Dollar Car Rental serves New York, the three airports in the city, Manhattan, and its surrounding area, so they will be able to assist with any questions or concerns that you may have during your trip.

• Dollar Car Rental is also a subsidiary of Hertz and is located at JFK Airport, LaGuardia Airport, Newark Airport, Manhattan, and Brooklyn.

Thrifty customer rating:

• 🟡 Regular overall value for money
• ✔️ Good cleanliness of the car
• 🟡 Poor Service at the rental desk
• 🟡 Slow Car hire pick-up process
• ✔️ Quick Car hire drop-off process

Book Now!

Factors to consider when choosing the Best Car Rental Companies in New York City

When looking for a car rental company, there are a variety of things that you should consider. Some of the important factors to take into account when choosing a rental car company are as follows:

Location and accessibility

When choosing a car, it is important to be aware of the location and accessibility in terms of getting to and from the car rental facility. Being accessible will allow you to reach your destination without any problems; the same applies to a location. You want to be able to get there quickly and efficiently, so check on both issues before deciding on the best place to rent a car in NYC.

Customer service

When looking to rent a car in New York, keep in mind that customer service is paramount. You will want to go with a company that will treat you with respect and professionalism, as well as provides you with quality service throughout your entire experience. Not only should the car rental company offer great customer service, but they should also be knowledgeable of the surrounding areas, events, and attractions around New York City.

Free car rental insurance

Be sure that the car rental company you pick offers free car insurance. Don’t forget to ask about any additional fees associated with your rental. There are certain times when you will be required to get a different form of insurance, such as in the case of non-choice or non-ownership. Also, consider whether there are any additional requirements for renting a car in New York City. This means you will have to ask what kind of ID and license you need to prove that you are old enough to rent a car.

Airport pickup services

Some car rental companies offer airport pickup services, allowing you to get your car at the airport. This is a time saver, as well as convenient. It is helpful for those who have lots of luggage and other traveling needs. However, this can be expensive as it will cost more than just picking up a car from the business itself.

Insurance

When looking for the best car rental in New York City, it is important to consider whether you need liability coverage as part of your rental. This will be required if you are renting a car for more than 30 days and is especially important if you do not have an auto policy or first-party insurance from your provider.

Experience

When choosing the best car rental company in NYC, you want to be sure of the experience that you are getting. The company should allow you to get some references for your trip with the car rental company and see if they have a large number of satisfied customers. Also, be sure to see if they have any complaints filed against them. This will help you evaluate the level of service that they provide as well as their reputation.

Conclusion

The car rental companies discussed in this article are reliable and can help you get the best car for your trip or business trip in New York City. They are all well-established and can meet all your needs perfectly. They provide a safe, secure, and affordable vehicle in which you will be able to explore New York City without any problems. Now, if you look for the cheapest way to rent a car in NYC, use our search engine below to find the best rental car deals in New York.

We hope you liked this article. Now you can continue reading our article about the differences between Avis, Budget, Hertz, Europcar, Payless, Sixt, Thrifty, Dollar, Alamo, National, or the article about TOP 10 Places to visit in Manhattan, or use our search engine below to book your car.

You may also be interested in…